May 08, 2013
Although we have been discussing the limitation of travel beyond 2,000 amot
) throughout Massekhet Eiruvin
, that applies only outside the city limits. If one resides in a large city, the entire city is considered to have the status of daled amot –
four cubits – and one can walk wherever he wants in it. This is also true if two cities are within 2,000 amot
of one another. In such a case, were one to place his eiruv
in the neighboring city, he would be permitted to walk anywhere in that city – even if it is well beyond the normal 2,000 amah
limit. The Mishnah
also brings the opinion of Rabbi Akiva
, who argues that movement within the larger city for people who are coming from a neighboring city would be limited to 2,000 amot
from their eiruv
, even within the precincts of the city.
Rabbi Akiva’s opinion is not accepted as the halakhah
. To illustrate this, the Gemara
tells of people who were arranging their eiruv
in a neighboring city so that they would be able to travel there on Shabbat
The Gemara relates that Mar Yehuda once found the residents of Mavrakhta placing their eiruvin in the synagogue of Beit Agovar. He said to them: Place your eiruv farther into the synagogue, so that more will be permitted to you, as the Shabbat limit is measured from the spot where the eiruv is deposited. Mar Yehuda holds that even when an eiruv is placed in an inhabited city, the two thousand cubits are measured from the location of the eiruv rather than from the edge of the city.
Rava said to him: Argumentative one [palga'ah]! With regard to the halakhot of eiruv, nobody is concerned about this opinion of Rabbi Akiva, as the halakhah is in accordance with the opinion of the Rabbis. Consequently, no matter where one places his eiruv in a city, the entire city is considered as though it were four cubits, and he is permitted to walk two thousand cubits beyond the edge of the city.
as someone always looking for a fight who took up positions that were not generally accepted. Rashi
explains the term to mean that he was known to argue with the Sages, who, in this case, had already ruled that the halakhah
follows the lenient position.
The example of a large city that appears in the Gemara is Antioch
, about which the baraita
teaches that someone who establishes his Shabbat
there can walk its full length and breadth, its size notwithstanding.
Antioch in Northern Syria was one of the largest cities in the world during the ancient period. Since it was built over a period of time – and, at its peak, was actually composed of four separate, joined cities – it was not well planned, part of the reason that it covered such a large area. During the Talmudic period, about 600,000 people lived there.
This essay is based upon the insights and chidushim of Rabbi Steinsaltz, as published in the English version of the Koren Talmud Bavli with Commentary by Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz, and edited and adapted by Rabbi Shalom Berger. To learn more about the Steinsaltz Daf Yomi initiative, click here.
To dedicate future editions of Steinsaltz Daf Yomi, perhaps in honor of a special occasion or